Wednesday, 18 April 2012

Dissertation

Extended project dissertation
Summary
For my extended project I chose to create a dissertation on a controversial subject that I am interested in, after weighing up the potential options I chose to do the subject of cannabis because it is such a recognised material, everyone knows about it, everyone has an opinion about it and is a very hot topic in government for whether or not cannabis should be made legal. I planned to interview people on both sides of the fence to find out the general opinion and use that as evidence in my dissertation, I have watched several documentaries that I will later talk about and break down and I have also looked at lots of government legislation, both from the UK and America to see what the governments opinion is on the matter. My aim of this dissertation is to simply present the facts to whom ever may be reading this and hopefully help shape opinions of those who do not know much on the subject, my aim is not to give a bias argument one way or another as I believe it is important to understand both sides of an argument but hopefully after you have read this there will be plenty of information for you to discuss with others and formulate your own opinion.
Introduction
Since the 60’s and the dawn of the hippies, the subject of drugs has been a very popular and controversial subject among the general public and governments, in particular cannabis. Cannabis is a huge part of many young people’s lives, whether they smoke it or not somebody has some sort of connection to it, through friends or even families, the simple fact of the matter is everyone has a valid opinion on the drug which is something I find very interesting which is why I have chosen to write about it in this dissertation. In the UK alone there are 62 million people, it is estimated that over 50% have smoked cannabis at some point in their lives and the vast majority of these smoked the drug when they were between the ages of 15 and 25, Cannabis is the drug most likely to be used. The 2005/06 BCS indicates that 8.7% of 16 to 59 year olds reported using cannabis in the last year (2004). The amount of people estimated to be regular users of cannabis in 2003 exceeded three million as shown in the graph below taken from the independent drug monitoring unit’s website.
Year
% Busted Cannabis offences
Avg Duration (yrs)
Busts /use year
Convictions over avg duration
% Regular Users in survey
Estimated Number of Regular Users
1994
21.2%
9.18
2.31%
270250
75.5%
961,073
1995
25.3%
8.69
2.91%
295695
85.9%
1,005,198
1997
21.0%
9.45
2.23%
362966
70.1%
1,209,383
1998
23.2%
12.78
1.82%
605532
67.3%
1,753,261
1999
21.4%
11.48
1.86%
655547
71.0%
2,175,048
2000
19.6%
11.42
1.71%
718519
68.5%
2,516,565
2001
18.2%
11.54
1.58%
768654
73.6%
3,106,950
2002
15.1%
12.80
1.18%
850228
58.2%
3,273,777
2003
17.0%
11.39
1.50%
839902
68.0%
3,350,801
1994-2003
18.2%
10.89
1.67%
818891
67.9%
2,150,228

The graph also shows that the number was on the rise, over the course of 9 years the number increased from 961073 to 3350801 which is a huge increase and the drug has only got more popular since a further 9 years later the amount of regular cannabis users in the UK is estimated to be around 6 million. Furthermore this graph is based on the amount of regular cannabis users by recorded cannabis offences; try to comprehend the number of users that have never been caught, as a young person myself I can say that roughly 40% of people I know have definitely smoked cannabis on more than one or two occasions, about 30% of these do it regularly and I know very few of those have ever been charged or even cautioned by the authorities for cannabis related offences, whether or not this is representative of the population of the UK I cannot be sure but it does make me wonder if the estimated numbers of people that regularly smoke are anywhere close to accurate but we can never know for sure. What we can be sure of is that the prohibition of cannabis, just like the prohibition of alcohol in America in the 1920’s is failing, I hope within the next few pages to explain why.
Now for a little history on the plant that has so many people in vigorous debate, the earliest recorded use of cannabis came from china in 2727 B.C when the Chinese used marijuana as a medicine, in 500 A.D cannabis reaches Europe by way of India and Africa. In 1492 Christopher Columbus bring cannabis sativa (particular breed of cannabis) to the new world, in 1619 Jamestown colony law required all settlers to grow cannabis due to the amount of money it generated for the community, 1797 in America George Washington’s primary crop grown at Mount Vernon was cannabis. The sultan of Turkey in 1876 gave the united states of America marijuana as a gift which lead to Turkish smoking parlours popping up all over north-eastern America in 1880, in 1891 our very own Queen Victoria is prescribed marijuana to relieve menstrual cramps. Henry Ford’s first model T (first car made by Ford about which Henry Ford famously said “You can have any colour you want, as long as it’s black) is made with hemp plastic and runs on hemp ethanol (hemp is a substance derived from the cannabis plant that was what paper was originally made from but it is very versatile and can be used for more than paper). In 1937 federal law bans marijuana in America and made illegal in the UK in 1928 however in 1942 the U.S military used marijuana as a ‘truth serum’. In 1965 1 million Americans had tried marijuana, 1972 led to 24 million Americans having tried marijuana and in the 1980’s Ronald Reagan with the Reagan administration begins its war on drugs and during the 1980’s it was estimated that someone was arrested every 38 seconds for violating a cannabis law, proposition 215 passes in California in 1996 making marijuana legal for medicinal purposes, and now marijuana is America’s number 1 cash crop generating $36 billion a year.
Research
Statistics and a very brief history aside I think it’s very important to begin with the opinions of the people who are most commonly associated with smoking cannabis, by this I mean young people, to get this information, I scheduled interviews with six people that I know, three of them believe cannabis should be legal (for group), the other three disagree (against group). I asked these six to prepare answerers for the question “what are your opinions on the legalisation of cannabis and why?” to which they would answer and I would then follow up with a second question relevant to their personalised answer and so on and finally would ask the question “Is the prohibition of marijuana succeeding?”. The first person I interviews was an 18 year old male and considered himself a strong Christian and was a part of the against group, in response to my first set question he replied with various valid point’s for being against such as his religion, “As a Christian I find that it is good to have a strong sense of morals, smoking anything can be harmful to your health and harm those around you through secondary smoke, smoking should never be encouraged no matter what form it is in, especially when it is mixed with glass shards and heaven only knows what else. If cannabis was made legal things could get out of control, I have never smoked myself but I know enough about the health affects to know it’s a bad idea” this is a very valid point, inhaling smoke cannot be good for you, can it? Well inhaling shards of glass certainly isn’t however cannabis itself has shown no evidence of physically harming the body, since records began nobody has ever actually died from smoking cannabis, however it has been linked to damaging somebody’s mental health, I personally know of one person in his late 40’s that developed ‘paranoid schizophrenia’ due to smoking cannabis an awful lot during his teenage years however cannabis supporters have an argument against this as well, they say that there is no evidence to suggest that cannabis actually causes these things to happen, which again is true but evidence gathered dose show that if somebody has an underlying mental illness, cannabis can bring it out so it starts having an affect on that person. I think this shows that cannabis clearly isn’t for everybody, but when I said that  to someone in the ‘for group’ they responded as such “Of course cannabis isn’t for everybody, a lot of anti-cannabis people seem to think that if cannabis is made legal society will crumble due to everyone sitting in their houses doing nothing but smoking marijuana, the truth is people are not mindless sheep, if they don’t want to smoke they won’t just like some people don’t drink and people don’t smoke tobacco. In all honesty I believe that the law is not stopping people from smoking it, if they want to they will which is why I don’t think legalising will have a large affect on the country at all.” I must admit that I do agree with this, the government appears to think that if cannabis is legalised, people would stop going to work and society would grind to a holt, this simply wouldn’t be the case, if somebody wanted to smoke cannabis, they would so if it was legalised not much would really happen. I went back to the for group for this next extract because I found it very interesting, the second person in the ‘for group’ stated “If cannabis was legal, all the problems with it would no longer be problems, or at least the vast majority of problems. Cannabis being cut with things like glass and brick dust is only an issue due to it being illegal, if the drug was legal is would be safely regulated and appropriately taxed which would probably end the recession, arguably it could put strain on the NHS but the revenue generated by the tax would nullify the impact, Studies have sufficiently shown that it has positive medical effects being used in treatments. I'm also for it being used industrially for fuel and such, as some studies have shown it to be very affective which would end the oil crisis and lastly, all the current system is doing is putting money into the hands of criminals, criminals that would use this money for other criminal activities, due to this system regular weed smokers that are really just regular people are giving money to these dealers for cannabis, making them tax free money while the dealers also live off benefits. Legalise, it’s the only logical option” – I found this answer most interesting from all of my interviewees, it made a lot of sense to me. For my last question I asked if cannabis prohibition was working, unsurprisingly every single person replied “No” which considering what has already been said makes sense. The rest of content from my interviews I found to be the same or simply just wrong due to answers like “It’s Immoral and kills people” so I decided not to use it, although the fact that it could be considered immoral can be touched on, if someone abuses cannabis, smokes it every day and becomes a very boring individual doing nothing with their lives, is it immoral? They certainly are not taking the moral high ground, they could be damaging relationships with friends and family, and being a general drain on society which is definitely immoral, all in all on this subject I think that it depends on the person who is using cannabis, by this I mean that in general a person is either immoral or moral, cannabis doesn’t change this, but could amplify someone’s immoral character.
Discussion
I watched several documentaries on the subject of cannabis for some more research, some for cannabis being legal and some with a neutral view, however I found it very difficult to find full documentaries entirely about why cannabis is bad and should illegal, only short anti marijuana adverts, the closest I came to finding an anti cannabis documentary is a couple of documentaries by the BBC which seem to be firmly neutral but certainly don’t promote the use of the drug. The first documentary I watch was an hour and 40 minute feature called the union, this documentary was a pro cannabis documentary called ‘The Union’ with the tagline “The business behind getting high”. This documentary claims to hold ‘the truth’ about why cannabis is illegal and how it is a big government conspiracy which is always fun to hear about. The documentary begins with the history of cannabis, unfortunately because the documentary is American most of the things it says mainly applies to America, but given that Britain is highly Americanised and very similar I find that it fits quite well. At the beginning the documentary talks about hemp, how hemp was used for paper, even the declaration of independence (the laws of the founding father’s three of these were George Washington, Benjamin Franklin and Thomas Jefferson) was written on hemp. Hemp was also used to make clothes, even fuel later on and was
generally a very useful material although seeing as I have already spoken about the history I will move onto the facts. The documentary’s first subject is the study that was supposed to have shown that cannabis kills brain cells – don’t do it, The Union refuted these claim with the argument that the only study done to back this up was done over 30 years ago in the 70’s in which some scientists strapped a mask to a chimp covering the face and nose and then pumped the equivilent of 63 joints worth of cannabis into the chimp through the mask in 5 minutes with no air inbetween which lead to the chimps dying after 90 days due to a lack of brain cells, The union argues that this study is highly flawed and even ridiculous, for starters they say that 63 joints in 5 minuets is a joke, nobody can even come close smoke that amount in 5 minutes, it usually takes about 5 minutes to finish one joint, especially with no air inbetween which is the key part of their argument, they say that with no air they are sufforcating the chimp which kills braincells anyway we can it really be trusted? The Union talks a lot about the benefits of medicinal marijuana in california, one example they give is of a man with Multiple sclerosis (abbreviated to MS, known as disseminated sclerosis or encephalomyelitis disseminata) is an inflammatory disease in which the fatty myelin sheaths around the axons of the brain and spinal cord are damaged, leading to demyelination and scarring as well as a broad spectrum of signs and symptoms.. The man they visit has been prescribed medicinal marijuana to help his symptoms, when we first see the man he is violently shaking all over the place, he can hardly talk and when he does talk it is next to impossible to work out what he is trying to say, after somebody gives him some medicinal marijuana he violent shaking calms down, he is able to talk and is understandable, the man goes on to talk about how he thinks it is “a joke” that cannabis is still illegal, he uses himself as an example “I mean look at me, you saw me earlier and look at me now. I am able to sit here and have a conversation with you” as a viewer I found the results startling, I assumed that medicinal marijuana was prescribed to simply help people with the pain of a serious disease, but this actually seemed to highly suppress the shaking and slurred speech, it wasn’t completely gone but the results clearly showed a drastic change which made me think that maybe more places should introduce the drug to help people with conditions like with Multiple sclerosis, cancer and other serious illnesses. The documentary also spoke rather extensively about the kind of people under the current system that bring marijuana to the public, during this section they visited a province in western Canada called British Columbia, an area famous for its natural beauty, but also highly famous for, you guessed it, cannabis. The presenter went out onto the streets of cities in America and asked the general public what they thought of when the presenter said “British Columbia”, surprisingly about 80% of people replied with “BC bud” which is a slang term for the cannabis that comes from the British Columbia region. In British Columbia it is estimated that for every 100 houses there is one ‘grow op’ which is short for grow operation, which is a house that is used for growing and cultivating cannabis illegally, that is a lot of grow op’s, but it’s the people that run these grow op’s that the documentary was interested in, their cameras were given permission by the owner of one grow op in BC to go inside and film and ask questions although obviously many precautions were taken by the owner to ensure no people that worked there or the location would be given away, the people that worked they carried weapons and wore coloured bandannas around their faces so they could not be seen, due to the colouring of the bandanna it became clear very quickly that this grow op was run by a violent gang. The documentary also spoke to two dealers asking them various questions, the dealers often crudely boasted about how much money they made, and when asked about whether or not cannabis should be legal, both them and the gang run grow op in BC replied with no, they are making far too much money because it is illegal, being illegal means it is expensive, and because it is expensive the suppliers and dealers make a lot of money, but do we really want this money to go to these violent gangs and criminals? The point the documentary is making here is that what the government is doing is making this money end up in the hands of criminals, they will use that money for other things, due to cannabis being illegal it funds gangs and they buy guns with the money which are used to kill their rivals, if it was legal the drug could be efficiently taxed and go to helping communities and fund government spending. Towards the end of the documentary the focus switches back to the medicinal purposes, but this time as to why the drug is illegal. Corporations, big ones, the privatised prisons and the medical companies, in the documentary a chief medical advisor was asked “Is there any other known substance on earth with more medical benefits than marijuana” his answer was simple one word answer, “No” and according to the documentary this scares large medical companies, if a plant that someone can grow in their own house, costs next to nothing and lasts a lifetime and can counteract everything from the common cold to with Multiple sclerosis is legalised then they lose out on a lot of money, proof of this? A small medical company in America was tasked with recreating marijuana in a form that would be very profitable, the creation? Marinol, a drug with the same molecular structure of cannabis, same compounds and works in the same way, even producing the same side effects as cannabis such as being hungry, laughter and happiness sometimes but doesn’t always work, Makes you think. The documentary also talks about the prison systems, privatised prisons are all over America, this means that they actually make money from people being in the prison system and as a result they push for longer harder sentences for smaller crimes, such as marijuana possession, so if cannabis is legalised both medical companies and privatised prison systems would lose a lot of money, is this corrupt, or is it for good? On the one hand we have jobs being created by these large, tax paying industries, on the other hand, medical companies are trying to rip the public off and these private prison systems want more people to go to their prisons, no matter the offence.
A neutral documentary I watched was one done by the BBC, it had both pro’s and con’s about cannabis, but I am going to focus on the Cons from this documentary to balance the argument more. The main con of cannabis in this documentary is a case study of a young boy that began smoking weed at the age of 14, he is now a paranoid schizophrenic, schizophrenia is a mental disorder characterized by a breakdown of thought processes and by poor emotional responsiveness. It most commonly manifests itself as auditory hallucinations, paranoid or bizarre delusions, or disorganized speech and thinking, and it is accompanied by significant social or occupational dysfunction. His reasons for his condition have been linked to marijuana use, although there is no solid evidence link the two, it has been suggested that marijuana only causes this to happen with prolonged vast amounts of use when the subject has an underlying mental illness, it works by sort of unlocking the condition hidden away in the subjects mind.
Now for some government legislation, the arguments they use to say cannabis should remain illegal. David Cameron himself has admitted to smoking pot in his Eton days, he was one of several pupils to be gated for a week because of this offence, this means he was not allowed to leave the school grounds or be visited by friends or family and yet under Tory government David himself said that cannabis would not be legalised under his party, they reclassified the drug to a class B from a class C which means that anyone caught in possession of cannabis should be jailed for between 3 months and 5 years, receive a minimum fine of £2,500 and have a criminal record for the rest of their lives although in most cases of being caught with cannabis possession it is dealt by roadside with a caution, the third time is more serious and could result with a prison sentence. Possession of cannabis is a bit of a grey area in England this map below shows different countries policies on the drug. Gradually however it would seem that cannabis may indeed be legalised sometime soon probably within the next 20 or so years, recently there has been a debate in the house of commons discussing whether or not cannabis should be legal, and they are becoming more and more common. Maybe soon it will be legalised? Although we cannot be sure.
Britain is in orange, which means illegal but often unenforced, whether this means that the police are slowly giving up I’m not sure, but compare it to other countries like the United Arab Emirates where they have a zero any drug policy and offenders can get a lifetime in prison for a small cannabis offence, Britain clearly is not that keen on arresting cannabis offenders. Looking at the map we can also see what places have legalised the drug, which brings me onto Amsterdam, a place I would have to touch on at some point in this dissertation. In Amsterdam cannabis is legal, loads of tourists descend on Amsterdam each year, not for the culture, but for the coffee shops, the coffee shop in Amsterdam is a place where you can go and buy cannabis then sit in the shop and smoke it, it is more of a tourist attraction seeing as through some research I discovered that although the locals do go there occasionally, it is not a big part of daily life, everything there runs fine however there are a lot of social issues in Amsterdam, particularly the famous red light district. In the red light district there is crime, prostitution and general dirtiness, whether this is because of the coffee shops we cannot be sure, it is most probably a third variable, a country with a red light district needs to introduce something to get the tourists over in order to have some sort of appeal, would people visit Amsterdam if cannabis wasn’t legal? Probably not so it is most likely that the coffee shops are there to generate money for the economy through tourism, but there are coffee shops on almost every street corner. One of the oldest coffee shops was called ‘Mellow Yellow’ and was opened in 1967, it is run by two British Hippie types. The Coffee shop draws people in from all places to see the legendary building and is featured in one of the BBC’s documentaries that I watched, they say that in Amsterdam, cannabis being legal is a very normal thing, it’s similar to going to the pub for a pint, there are laws in place to stop the drug getting into the hands of youngsters which work very well, you must be over 18 to buy marijuana in a coffee shop, and because its legal there are no dealers selling the drug to under age people. The reason I feel it is relevant to talk about Amsterdam is that it shows a functioning society that has legalised cannabis which makes it a great case study to get information from, granted it has its flaws, but all societies do.
Now we move away from the opinions of people, documentaries and politicians and onto the media, in his part I’m talking about music. The majority of music gives off a message that cannabis is a good thing, it doesn’t tend to say why but it does glamorise the drug beyond belief, but can they really be believed? Artist sing often about smoking weed, Afro man, Snoop Dogg, Black Sabbath, Cypress Hill, Pink Floyd, Nirvana, Rick James and so many more. Are they making young people want to smoke weed in the wrong way? Well many people think so “I’m worried that when my kids grow up they will start to smoke cannabis a lot and I don’t want them to fail school, they need a good education, I think that the most common source of influential drug use is music, just last week my 6 year old boy was running around the houses singing “My eyes are red, I’ve been burning” which is apparently and Ed Sheeran lyric” – From a concerned mother of two. These days many old hippies argue that music has changed what smoking marijuana was all about, in the 60’s it was about listening to great music and ‘sticking it to the man’ they stood for something and it wasn’t just mindless, these days in music it seems to be all about smoking a joint, smacking a ‘bitch’ up or holding up a store, they should not be linked, it was once about peace, now it seems to be highly the opposite. Of course this isn’t true for all music, but the most popular music seems to give off this message which is possibly why young people smoking weed in the media gets so much bad press. But other music represents cannabis in a good way, take for example “This afternoon” by Nickleback, a more mainstream and well known band that opens with the lyrics “Looking like another Bob Marley day, hitting from the bong like a diesel train and I’m down for hanging out this afternoon” and “We got weeds in the back yard 4 feet tall, Cheech and Chong probably would have smoked them all, so I’m on the couch this afternoon” the song is about hanging out with friends and having a good time, the song isn’t centred around marijuana but it suggests that it just adds to having a good time with friends, whether or not it changes how people think I don’t know, it is quite subtle and children wouldn’t really be affected by this however these lyrics do raise the question of should this really be a mainstream band if it is promoting these kind of ideals? If a child is raised listening to this kind of music would it have an effect on how the child grows up? The child most probably wouldn’t know what the song is talking about, but probably will later in life, it might think that smoking cannabis a lot is ok, whether it is or not is for you to decide, but the promotion of cannabis in mainstream music could be a problem, particularly for young minds.
Conclusion
To summarise I believe that I have reached my set goals and aims, referring back to my introduction I stated that my aims were to inform, not try to convey my opinion, I believe I have brought the facts to the audience, and maybe even busted a few myths such as the cannabis kills brain cells study that I spoke about with the chimps that were hooked up to gas masks and forced to inhale the equivalent of 63 joints in 5 minutes with no breaks in-between. I have done my best to explain both sides of the story however I did come across the problem of not finding a huge amount of content on anti-cannabis facts, most of what I found was seemingly empty propaganda with no evidence to back itself up, such as smoking marijuana will make you stupid and lead to a life of depression and failure which is clearly wrong, president Obama and many other presidents admitted to smoking marijuana at a young age, even David Cameron, Richard Nixon even famously said “Yes I smoked it, but I didn’t Inhale”. So what does this tell us? From the information I have gathered and displayed in this dissertation I personally believe that smoking cannabis can obviously not be promoted, there cannot be huge billboards saying things like “Come get high” because we could potentially have a generation of delusional and lazy people, but then again, judging by the evidence presented and the simple facts, Cannabis probably should be legal. If I was to make the rules I would legalise yet tax it a lot, and put every penny of that tax into the health care system. With Cannabis being illegal, we see money being put into the hands of criminals, which funds gang culture and other crime, it means that state prisons are filled in countries like the UK which costs the tax payers and government an awful lot of money because they need to pay for food for the prisoners, heating, electricity, bedrolls, clothes, the list is long and expensive. In my opinion cannabis should be treated like alcohol or cigarettes, you need to be over 18 to buy, maybe even make it 21 to ensure that whoever is buying the product is fully developed so it doesn’t have an effect of young people and make sure all people know the true risks of using it, for example on a pack of marijuana cigarettes it might say “Warning, may cause damaged to mental health”. If this was to happen the government would spend less money, prisons would not be overcrowded and there would not be so much money put into organised crime. That’s just what I think from the evidence gathered, how about you? All opinions are welcome.

No comments:

Post a Comment